Everyday Sun Sticks To Try: A Skin-Saving Trio for Oily, Dry & Sensitive Skin

Sun Stick Showdown: Nature Republic, TOCOBO & AHC

(Plus: Which One Survived My Makeup Test?)

I’ve been on a mission to find the perfect sunscreen stick for touch-ups, especially over makeup. After testing Abib, Etude House, and THE FACE SHOP, I decided to try three new contenders: Nature Republic California Aloe Fresh Powdery Sun Stick, TOCOBO Cotton Soft Sun Stick, and AHC Natural Perfection Double Shield Sun Stick. Here’s how they fared!

Nature Republic California Aloe Fresh Powdery Sun Stick SPF50+ PA++++

What is it? A lightweight, aloe-infused sun stick with a “powdery” finish designed to control shine and soothe skin. Contains 80% aloe vera extract and hyaluronic acid for hydration.

My thoughts:

The mint-green packaging screams "fresh," and the formula lives up to it! This stick has a subtle herbal scent (think aloe with a hint of mint) and glides on smoothly without tugging. The “powdery” claim is real—it leaves a soft, semi-matte finish that’s perfect for oily or combo skin. I noticed zero white cast, even on my deeper skin tone. The rectangular shape hugs curves like the jawline well, but the edges felt slightly bulky around the nose. Over makeup, it blended seamlessly without disturbing my foundation, though it did leave a tiny powdery residue on the stick. A winner for shine control!

TOCOBO Cotton Soft Sun Stick SPF50+ PA++++

What is it? A mineral-based sunscreen stick with cotton extract and centella asiatica for sensitive skin. Advertised as a “weightless, airy” formula that feels like cotton on skin.

My thoughts:

The packaging is minimalist and chic—perfect for tossing in a purse. This stick has a faint, clean cotton scent (almost laundry-like) and a creamy texture that melts into the skin. The “cotton soft” name is spot-on; it feels like a velvety cushion during application. As a mineral sunscreen, it does leave a slight white cast initially, but gentle patting blends it into a natural finish. Over makeup, it worked well but added a subtle luminosity. The rounded edges made contour application easy, though the formula felt a tad sticky before fully settling. Ideal for sensitive or dry skin types!

AHC Natural Perfection Double Shield Sun Stick SPF50+ PA++++

What is it? A hybrid sunscreen (physical + chemical) with dual UV protection. Infused with tea tree extract and adenosine for calming and anti-aging benefits.

My thoughts:

The sleek blue packaging feels luxe, and the slanted applicator tip is genius for precision. This stick has a mild herbal scent (thanks to tea tree) and a buttery texture that glides like a dream. Zero white cast, and the finish is dewy but not greasy—a great option for dry or normal skin. Over makeup, it impressed me the most: it didn’t disturb my foundation and even added a healthy glow. The slanted design made reapplying around the nose and eyelids effortless. The only downside? A tiny bit of transfer onto the stick, but easily wiped off. A multitasker for glow lovers!

The Verdict

I tested all three over light foundation (no powder) on a humid day:

• Nature Republic kept me matte for hours—perfect for oily skin or touch-ups in sweaty weather. The powdery finish felt fresh, but dry skin folks might find it too absorbing.
• TOCOBO’s cotton-soft texture was heavenly, but the slight stickiness and minimal white cast make it better for bare skin or light makeup days. Sensitive skin MVP!
• AHC stole my heart for its glow-enhancing, makeup-friendly formula. The hybrid protection and elegant application make it my top pick for daily wear, especially under or over makeup.

Final ranking:

1. AHC (best all-rounder)
2. Nature Republic (shine control queen)
3. TOCOBO (sensitive skin savior)